Обсуждение: Fwd: Re: Comparing PostgreSQL and Oracle stability

Поиск
Список
Период
Сортировка

Fwd: Re: Comparing PostgreSQL and Oracle stability

От
Jan Pruner
Дата:
Support PostgreSQL in some way hierarchical query like Oracle does?
Select ... start with ... connect by ...  ???

JP

On Thursday 04 July 2002 11:18, you wrote:
> > I'm considering porting code from Oracle to PostgreSql. I'm looking
> > for opinions from people that are experienced with both PostgreSQL and
> > Oracle:
> >
> > 1) Is the stability better, equal or worse when comparing Oracle 9i?
> > 2) Are there any performance issues to be aware of when comparing
> > PostgreSql an d Oracle (on the same hardware configuration) - eg. size
> > of table colums, count of records in tables (and indexes).
> > 3) And how about the work for DB administrators - are things simpler
> > or more complicated?
>
> First off, I don't have much experience with Oracle, but I have done a
> couple things with it, and one of my colleagues has used it much more
> extensively.
>
> 1) stability - I have not had stability problems with a recent release of
> postgresql. The developers sometimes mention potential problems, but I
> haven't encountered one (at least after 7.1, before that I seem to remember
> a couple minor issues). I haven't heard of any problems with oracle.
>
> 2) I can't provide you with any meaningful info about performance. I didn't
> do any scientific performance comparison. One thing I can say, is that my
> colleague needed to spend a lot of time giving hints to oracle because
> (according to him) the planner was really bad and frequently made planning
> errors.
>
> 3) Much easier to administrate postgres. I gave up trying to get oracle
> working myself.
>
> Regards,
>     Jeff
>
>
>
> ---------------------------(end of broadcast)---------------------------
> TIP 1: subscribe and unsubscribe commands go to majordomo@postgresql.org

--
         Pruner Jan
       jan@pruner.cz
     http://jan.pruner.cz/
-----------------------------
Only Robinson Crusoe had all his work done by Friday

-------------------------------------------------------




Re: Fwd: Re: Comparing PostgreSQL and Oracle stability

От
Nils Höglund
Дата:
> Support PostgreSQL in some way hierarchical query like Oracle does?
> Select ... start with ... connect by ...  ???

Haven't found any support of that in postgresql.

This is really a functionallity I miss (or have missed ;).

I solve the problem by sorting posts in my application (JSP). Works pretty
well, however - I would like the db to do the work.

> > 2) I can't provide you with any meaningful info about performance. I didn't
> > do any scientific performance comparison. One thing I can say, is that my
> > colleague needed to spend a lot of time giving hints to oracle because
> > (according to him) the planner was really bad and frequently made planning
> > errors.

I agree with your colleague. Writing you're queries "right" is
really important in Oracle. :)


--
/Nils Höglund, Naqua KB

E-mail:         nils@naqua.se
Web:            http://www.naqua.se/
Home Phone:     +46 (0)18  30 09 19
Cellular Phone: +46 (0)709 91 97 65
Address:        Nya Valsätrav. 26 B
                SE-756 46
                Uppsala, Sweden