Обсуждение: Re: Vá: [BUGS] Bug #519: Bug in order by clausule

Sandor.Vig@audi.hu writes:
> As you see ONLY the 00000000000000CS ID is missplaced,
> the others are in correct sequence! This isn't a locale specific
> sort order. (I have RED HAT 7.1, with Hungarian settings,

Still looks like locale to me.  Exactly what LANG or LC_xxx settings
are you using for the postmaster?

            regards, tom lane

On Mon, 26 Nov 2001, Tom Lane wrote:

> Sandor.Vig@audi.hu writes:
> > As you see ONLY the 00000000000000CS ID is missplaced,
> > the others are in correct sequence! This isn't a locale specific
> > sort order. (I have RED HAT 7.1, with Hungarian settings,
>
> Still looks like locale to me.  Exactly what LANG or LC_xxx settings
> are you using for the postmaster?

As a note, using a test program with LC_COLLATE=hu_HU, I get the
following strcoll values. ( I'm sort of assuming that hu_HU would
be the default setting for Hungary ;) )

CS <=> CY = 1
CS <=> CZ = -1

That seems to imply that for hu_HU CSs collation value is between
CY and CZ.

Stephan Szabo <sszabo@megazone23.bigpanda.com> writes:
> As a note, using a test program with LC_COLLATE=hu_HU, I get the
> following strcoll values. ( I'm sort of assuming that hu_HU would
> be the default setting for Hungary ;) )

On HPUX 10.20, I get these results:

$ cat hudata
 00000000000000CP
 00000000000000CQ
 00000000000000CR
 00000000000000CT
 00000000000000CU
 00000000000000CV
 00000000000000CW
 00000000000000CX
 00000000000000CY
 00000000000000CS
 00000000000000CZ
 00000000000000D0
 00000000000000D1
 00000000000000D2
 00000000000000D3
$ LANG='C' sort hudata
 00000000000000CP
 00000000000000CQ
 00000000000000CR
 00000000000000CS
 00000000000000CT
 00000000000000CU
 00000000000000CV
 00000000000000CW
 00000000000000CX
 00000000000000CY
 00000000000000CZ
 00000000000000D0
 00000000000000D1
 00000000000000D2
 00000000000000D3
$ LANG='hu_HU.iso88592' sort hudata
 00000000000000CP
 00000000000000CQ
 00000000000000CR
 00000000000000CT
 00000000000000CU
 00000000000000CV
 00000000000000CW
 00000000000000CX
 00000000000000CY
 00000000000000CZ
 00000000000000CS
 00000000000000D0
 00000000000000D1
 00000000000000D2
 00000000000000D3

(HPUX is picky about locale names... 'hu_HU' doesn't work...)

This doesn't seem to entirely square with the results you two get,
but it sure does look like "CS" sorts in non-ASCII order in HU locale.

            regards, tom lane

On Mon, 26 Nov 2001, Tom Lane wrote:

> (HPUX is picky about locale names... 'hu_HU' doesn't work...)

> This doesn't seem to entirely square with the results you two get,
> but it sure does look like "CS" sorts in non-ASCII order in HU locale.

I tried it with the full locale name you used and sort with that data and
still got the same result as I did before (CY/CS/CZ) which seems odd that
it's different, but it's on a Debian box which I'd guess should be pretty
similar to the Red Hat machine of the original complaintant (sp?).