Re: Log rotation

This thread seems to have died without a conclusion. AFAICS, we have 5 
options:

. the apache program - see below pro: robust, portable, extremely well tested, no effort to import con: possible
licenseissues, limited features
 
. Peter Eisentraut's program pro: portable, better featured, no license issues con: code state uncertain, less well
tested
. the Afilias script pro: well featured, no license issues con: not portable (relies on perl), testing status
uncertain
. something new pro: no license issues, can make as featured as desired, portable con: lots of effort, untested
. nothing pro: no effort, no license issues :-) con: feature is desired

The issues seem to have been thrashed out ad nauseam. Surely we can put 
*something* in contrib for this? After all, nobody has to use it if they 
don't want to.

cheers

andrew






I wrote:

>
>
> Tom Lane wrote:
>
>> Andrew Dunstan <andrew@dunslane.net> writes:
>>  
>>
>>> Did anything ever come from this thread? 
>>> http://archives.postgresql.org/pgsql-hackers/2003-05/msg00603.php 
>>> (Heading: "Plan B for log rotation support: borrow Apache code")
>>>   
>>
>>
>> Only an entry on my depressingly long personal to-do list :-(
>>
>> I did take a look at the Apache rotator program, and found that it was
>> probably more trouble to adopt than it's worth.  It seemed to depend on
>> a lot of configuration and library-routine infrastructure that we don't
>> share.  (No big surprise; I suppose someone trying to pull out a random
>> bit of our backend code would be at least as unhappy.)  I suspect it
>> would be less trouble, as well as legalistically cleaner, to write our
>> own from scratch.
>>
>> Andrew Sullivan offered Afilias' rotator script awhile back also.
>> I think that works fine if you like a Perl script.
>>
>>  
>>
>
> FWIW, in less than 30 minutes I took the log rotator from apache 
> 1.3.29 (i.e. the latest non-APR version) and imported it into a fresh 
> postgreql tree. With very little massaging it built happily (see below).
>
> If it will advance matters, I can submit this as a patch filling the 
> currently empty contrib/apache_logging directory. You could be right 
> about the legal stuff - worth talking to the apache folks?
>
>
>
>