Re: monitoring CREATE INDEX [CONCURRENTLY]

Поиск
Список
Период
Сортировка
От Alvaro Herrera
Тема Re: monitoring CREATE INDEX [CONCURRENTLY]
Дата
Msg-id 20190212191632.GA28036@alvherre.pgsql
обсуждение исходный текст
Ответ на Re: monitoring CREATE INDEX [CONCURRENTLY]  (Alvaro Herrera <alvherre@2ndquadrant.com>)
Ответы Re: monitoring CREATE INDEX [CONCURRENTLY]  (Simon Riggs <simon@2ndquadrant.com>)
Re: monitoring CREATE INDEX [CONCURRENTLY]  (Tatsuro Yamada <yamada.tatsuro@lab.ntt.co.jp>)
Список pgsql-hackers
I added metrics for the validate_index phases; patch attached.  This is
still a bit raw, but it looks much better now.  Here's a sample
concurrent index build on a 100M tuple table.  There are no concurrent
transactions, so phases that wait for lockers don't appear.  I'm not
making any effort to report metrics during phase 6, note.  In phase 7
I'm currently reporting only tuple counts; I think it'd be better to
report block numbers.  

I don't show it here, but when an index is built on a partitioned table,
the "partitions done" number goes up all the way to "partitions total"
and the phases come and go for each partition.

One thing is clear: given the phase mechanics of varying durations, it
seems hard to use these numbers to predict total index build time.


     now      |                         phase                          | blocks total | blocks done | tuples total |
tuplesdone | partitions total | partitions done 
 

--------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------------+-----------------
 15:56:33.792 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |          32 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:33.805 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |         188 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
     [snip about 500 lines]
 15:56:41.345 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      439855 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:41.356 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      440288 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:41.367 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      440778 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:41.378 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      441706 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:41.389 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      442399 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:41.4   | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      442399 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 

     [snip 300 lines]        ... I'm not sure what happened in this 3 seconds period.  No metrics were being updated.

 15:56:44.65  | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      442399 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.661 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      442399 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.672 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      442399 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.682 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      442399 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.694 | building index (3 of 8): initializing (1/5)            |       442478 |      442399 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.705 | building index (3 of 8): sorting tuples, spool 1 (3/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.716 | building index (3 of 8): sorting tuples, spool 1 (3/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.727 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
  79057 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.738 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
 217018 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.75  | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
 353804 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.761 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
 487892 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:44.773 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
 634136 |                0 |               0
 
    [snip 660 lines]
 15:56:52.47  | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
99111337|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.482 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
99285701|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.493 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
99444763|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.505 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
99612313|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.516 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
99782666|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.528 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
99937524|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.54  | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.551 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.561 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.572 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.583 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.594 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.604 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.615 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.626 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.637 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.648 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.658 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.669 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.68  | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.691 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.701 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0 
 15:56:52.712 | building index (3 of 8): final btree sort & load (5/5) |       442478 |      442399 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.723 | validating index scan (phase 5 of 8)                   |       274194 |        1049 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.734 | validating index scan (phase 5 of 8)                   |       274194 |        2676 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.744 | validating index scan (phase 5 of 8)                   |       274194 |        2876 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:52.755 | validating index scan (phase 5 of 8)                   |       274194 |        4194 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
    [snip 400 lines]
 15:56:57.031 | validating index scan (phase 5 of 8)                   |       274194 |      268343 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.042 | validating index scan (phase 5 of 8)                   |       274194 |      268479 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.053 | validating index scan (phase 5 of 8)                   |       274194 |      270027 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.064 | validating index scan (phase 5 of 8)                   |       274194 |      271580 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.075 | validating index scan (phase 5 of 8)                   |       274194 |      273121 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.085 | sorting index scan results (phase 6 of 8)              |       274194 |      274193 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.096 | sorting index scan results (phase 6 of 8)              |       274194 |      274193 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.107 | sorting index scan results (phase 6 of 8)              |       274194 |      274193 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.118 | sorting index scan results (phase 6 of 8)              |       274194 |      274193 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.128 | sorting index scan results (phase 6 of 8)              |       274194 |      274193 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.139 | sorting index scan results (phase 6 of 8)              |       274194 |      274193 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.15  | sorting index scan results (phase 6 of 8)              |       274194 |      274193 |            0 |
      0 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.161 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
  50152 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.172 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
 175602 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.182 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
 305326 |                0 |               0
 
 15:56:57.193 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
 430142 |                0 |               0
 
      [snip 730 lines]
 15:57:05.003 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
99125556|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.013 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
99276471|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.024 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
99425041|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.035 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
99580174|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.045 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
99720505|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.056 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
99862311|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.067 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.077 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.088 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.099 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.109 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.12  | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.131 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.142 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.152 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.163 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
 15:57:05.174 | validate index heapscan (phase 7 of 8)                 |            0 |           0 |    100000000 |
100000000|                0 |               0
 
(2862 filas)

and then it's done.

-- 
Álvaro Herrera                https://www.2ndQuadrant.com/
PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Remote DBA, Training & Services

Вложения

В списке pgsql-hackers по дате отправления:

Предыдущее
От: Robbie Harwood
Дата:
Сообщение: Re: [PATCH v20] GSSAPI encryption support
Следующее
От: Stephen Frost
Дата:
Сообщение: Re: [PATCH v20] GSSAPI encryption support