Обсуждение: [RFC] SLIM Data Type - Compact JSON Alternative (17-62% smaller)

I'd like to propose a new data type for PostgreSQL: SLIM (Structured Lightweight Interchange Markup), a compact alternative to JSONB that achieves 17-62% storage reduction while remaining human-readable.


== The Problem ==

JSONB is great, but has inherent inefficiencies:
- Redundant field names in arrays of objects
- Verbose syntax (quotes, colons, brackets)
- Boolean representation uses 4-5 bytes each
- No format-level compression

For databases with millions of JSON documents, this adds up.


== SLIM Format ==

JSON:  {"users":[{"id":1,"name":"Alice","active":true},{"id":2,"name":"Bob","active":false}]}
SLIM:  {users:|2|id#,name,active?|1,Alice,T|2,Bob,F}

Savings: 45%

Key optimizations:
- Table format for arrays: schema once, data in rows
- Type markers: # (number), ? (boolean), ! (null)
- Compact booleans: T/F instead of true/false
- No quotes for simple strings


== Real-World Benchmarks ==

Tested on a production TimescaleDB database (74.9 million rows, 74 GB):

Format                    | Sample    | JSON    | SLIM    | Savings
--------------------------|-----------|---------|---------|--------
Object (token_metrics)    | 100K rows | 16 MB   | 13 MB   | 18.7%
Object (wallet_activity)  | 100K rows | 20 MB   | 16 MB   | 17.0%
Table format (arrays)     | 10K rows  | 580 KB  | 222 KB  | 61.7%

Extrapolated on 74 GB: 12.5-45.9 GB savings depending on data structure.


== Implementation ==

I've built a working PostgreSQL extension (pg_slim) that provides:
- Native SLIM data type with TOAST support
- Implicit casts to/from JSONB and TEXT
- Full operator support: ->, ->>, @>, <@, ?, ?|, ?&
- B-tree and hash indexing
- Comparison operators for sorting

Example usage:

    CREATE TABLE documents (id SERIAL PRIMARY KEY, data SLIM);
    INSERT INTO documents (data) VALUES ('{name:Alice,age:#30}'::slim);
    INSERT INTO documents (data) VALUES (slim_encode('{"name":"Bob"}'::jsonb));
    SELECT data->>'name' FROM documents;  -- Works like JSONB
    SELECT * FROM documents WHERE data @> '{name:Alice}'::slim;

The extension compiles and passes tests on PostgreSQL 15.


== Questions for Discussion ==

1. Is there community interest in a SLIM type?
2. Should this remain an extension or be considered for contrib/core?
3. Which index types should be prioritized (GIN support is planned)?
4. Any concerns about the format design?


== Links ==

- Extension: https://github.com/matteuccimarco/pg-slim
- Full RFC: https://github.com/matteuccimarco/pg-slim/blob/main/RFC-SLIM-TYPE.md
- SLIM spec: https://github.com/matteuccimarco/slim-protocol-core
- Benchmarks: https://github.com/matteuccimarco/pg-slim/blob/main/BENCHMARK-RESULTS.md

Looking forward to your feedback.

Best regards,
Marco Matteucci