Arguments Pro/Contra Software Raid

Hi,

I've just had some discussion with colleagues regarding the usage of
hardware or software raid 1/10 for our linux based database servers.

I myself can't see much reason to spend $500 on high end controller
cards for a simple Raid 1.

Any arguments pro or contra would be desirable.

 From my experience and what I've read here:

+ Hardware Raids might be a bit easier to manage, if you never spend a
few hours to learn Software Raid Tools.

+ There are situations in which Software Raids are faster, as CPU power
has advanced dramatically in the last years and even high end controller
cards cannot keep up with that.

+ Using SATA drives is always a bit of risk, as some drives are lying
about whether they are caching or not.

+ Using hardware controllers, the array becomes locked to a particular
vendor. You can't switch controller vendors as the array meta
information is stored proprietary. In case the Raid is broken to a level
the controller can't recover automatically this might complicate manual
recovery by specialists.

+ Even battery backed controllers can't guarantee that data written to
the drives is consistent after a power outage, neither that the drive
does not corrupt something during the involuntary shutdown / power
irregularities. (This is theoretical as any server will be UPS backed)


--
Regards,
Hannes Dorbath