Re: How best to index foreign key for inner join

Поиск
Список
Период
Сортировка
От Thom Brown
Тема Re: How best to index foreign key for inner join
Дата
Msg-id bddc86150911270312t12dec151yadd656f9bc435bdc@mail.gmail.com
обсуждение исходный текст
Ответ на How best to index foreign key for inner join  (Nathaniel Trellice <naptrel@yahoo.co.uk>)
Список pgsql-novice
2009/11/27 Nathaniel Trellice <naptrel@yahoo.co.uk>
Hello,

I'd appreciate advice anyone can offer on this simple, newbie
question. It really is a straightforward question, so please bare with
me if I don't explain it succinctly below.

I want to search a table based on criteria on both a column within
that table and a column within a joined table, and I'm trying to
figure out how to index things for my particular form of query. The
postgres manual is excellent, but it doesn't appear to answer this
question explicitly through a matching example, and I'm not very good
with indexing, so I'm seeking advice here (yet again).

E.g. Suppose I have 2 tables defined:

CREATE TABLE table1 (
 id      SERIAL PRIMARY KEY,
 name    text
);

CREATE TABLE table2 (
 x            real,
 y            real,
 t            timestampz,
 table1_id    integer REFERENCES table1 ON DELETE CASCADE
);

My queries upon these tables are, almost exclusively, asking for all
the records with a particular 'name' between a range of times 't', and
so are of the form:

SELECT table2.x, table2.y, table2.t
FROM table2, table1
WHERE
 table2.table1_id = table1.id    -- inner join
 AND table1.name = 'some_name'    -- criterion on table1
 AND table2.t BETWEEN some_t AND some_other_t;    --criterion on table2


What columns should I index in table2, and how: multi-column on
(table1_id, t), say, or multiple single column indexes, or only one
on 't'?

I guess the query might benefit from an index on table1's 'name'
column, but since there are, typically, only tens or hundreds of
records in table1, it might not be worth it. There are millions of
records in table2.

Thanks,

Nathaniel


Since for each row of table1 you'll be looking for multiple records on table2, I imagine you'd want to index table2.table1_id, and table2.t since that's what you're filtering on.  If table1 is particularly big, you might benefit from also indexing table1.name.

I personally prefer to use INNER JOIN syntax as it's clearer, although the query planner will probably be identical as it's clever that way:

SELECT table2.x, table2.y, table2.t
FROM table1
INNER JOIN table2 ON table1.id = table2.table1_id
AND table1.name = 'some_name'
WHERE table2.t BETWEEN some_t AND some_other_t;

Regards

Thom

В списке pgsql-novice по дате отправления:

Предыдущее
От: Nathaniel Trellice
Дата:
Сообщение: How best to index foreign key for inner join
Следующее
От: "Jean-Yves F. Barbier"
Дата:
Сообщение: Re: bytea and text