On Sun, Oct 05, 2025 at 10:30:53PM +0000, Ilyasov Ian wrote:
> Do we need info about recovery.conf here since patch applies only to
> master?
And actually, I think that you are pointing at a bug here.
pg_createsubscriber does updates of the control file but it includes
zero checks based on PG_CONTROL_VERSION to make sure that it is able
to work with a version compatible with what's on disk. The CRC check
would be reported as incorrect after calling get_controlfile(), but
it's disturbing to claim that the control file looks corrupted.
So, oops?
[.. checks ..]
The last control file update has been done in 44fe30fdab67, and
attempting to run pg_createsubscriber on a v17 cluster leads to:
$ pg_createsubscriber -D $HOME/data/5433 -P "host=/tmp port=5432" -d postgres
pg_createsubscriber: error: control file appears to be corrupt
So, yes, oops. We document that pg_cretesubscriber should have the
same major version as the source and target servers, which is good.
This error is no good, especially as checking it is just a few lines
of code, and that the take is actually PG_CONTROL_VERSION for control
file consistency.
--
Michael