On 24 April 2018 at 15:18, Magnus Hagander <magnus@hagander.net> wrote:
> Back when I was combating windows AV on a daily basis, this normally did not
> have the same effect. Just disabling the AV didn't actually remove the parts
> that caused issues, it just hid them. Actual uninstall is what was required.
Yep. Specifically, they tended to inject kernel hooks and/or load hook
DLLs that did funky and often flakey things. Often with poor awareness
of things like multiple processes opening one file for write at the
same time.
I think I heard that MS has cleaned up the situation with AV
considerably by offering more kernel infrastructure for it, and
restricting what you can do in terms of kernel extensions etc. But I
don't know how much.
In any case, do you think dropping a minidump at the point of failure
might be informative? It should contain the full memory mapping
information. For this purpose we could just create a crashdumps/
directory then abort() when we detect the error, and have the
buildfarm stop processing until someone can grab the tempdir with the
dumps, binaries, .pdb files, etc.
src/backend/port/win32/crashdump.c doesn't expose a helper function to
do all the dbghelp.dll messing around and create a crashdump, it only
allows that to be done via a crash handler. But it might make sense to
break out the actual "write a crash dump" part to a separately
callable function. I've looked at doing this before, but always got
stuck with the apparent lack of support in gdb or lldb to be used as a
library for self-dumping. You can always shell out to gcore I guess...
but ew. Or we can fork() and abort() the forked child like
https://github.com/RuntimeTools/gencore does, but again, ew.
I was thinking that maybe the buildfarm could just create crashdumps/
automatically, but then we'd need to have support infrastructure for
recording the Pg binaries and .pdb files along with the dumps,
rotating them so we don't run out of space, etc etc.
--
Craig Ringer http://www.2ndQuadrant.com/
PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Training & Services