Re: [HACKERS] logical decoding of two-phase transactions

Hi,



>> Uh? Simply rechecking if MyProc->decodeGroupLeader is NULL obviously
>> does not fix the race condition - it might get NULL right after the
>> check. So we need to either lookup the PROC again (and then get the
>> associated lwlock), or hold some other type of lock.
>>
>
> I realized my approach was short-sighted while coding it up. So now we
> lookup the leader pgproc, recheck if the XID is the same that we are
> interested in and go ahead.
>

I did some more gdb single-stepping and debugging on this. Introduced a few
more fetch pgproc using XID calls for more robustness. I am satisfied now from
my point of view with the decodegroup lock changes.

Also a few other changes related to cleanups and setting of the txn flags at
all places.

PFA, v2.0 of the patchset for today.

"make check-world" passes ok on these patches.

Regards,
Nikhils

>>
>>>>
>>>> 3) I don't quite understand why BecomeDecodeGroupMember does the
>>>> cross-check using PID. In which case would it help?
>>>>
>>>
>>> When I wrote this support, I had written it with the intention of
>>> supporting both 2PC (in which case pid is 0) and in-progress regular
>>> transactions. That's why the presence of PID in these functions. The
>>> current use case is just for 2PC, so we could remove it.
>>>
>>
>> Sure, but why do we need to cross-check the PID at all? I may be missing
>> something here, but I don't see what does this protect against?
>>
>
> The fact that PID is 0 in case of prepared transactions was making me
> nervous. So, I had added the assert that pid should only be 0 when
> it's a prepared transaction and not otherwise. Anyways, since we are
> dealing with only 2PC, I have removed the PID argument now. Also
> removed is_prepared argument for the same reason.
>
>>>
>>> Ok, I am looking at your provided patch and incorporating relevant
>>> changes from it. WIll submit a patch set soon.
>>>
>>
>> OK.
>>
> PFA, latest patch set.
>
> Regards,
> Nikhils
> --
>  Nikhil Sontakke                   http://www.2ndQuadrant.com/
>  PostgreSQL/Postgres-XL Development, 24x7 Support, Training & Services



-- 
 Nikhil Sontakke                   http://www.2ndQuadrant.com/
 PostgreSQL/Postgres-XL Development, 24x7 Support, Training & Services