Re: BUG #18829: RAISE NOTICE appends 's' to string in PostgreSQL 17.2

On Sun, Mar 2, 2025 at 11:09 AM Tom Lane <tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us> wrote:
>
> PG Bug reporting form <noreply@postgresql.org> writes:
> > In PostgreSQL 17.2, when using the RAISE NOTICE command with a string
> > variable, the output incorrectly appends an extra 's' to the string value.
>
> The substitution marker in plpgsql RAISE strings is just "%", not
> "%s" as it is in C, so this output is expected.  That wasn't the best
> design perhaps, but it's impossible to change it now.
>
> > This issue does not occur when running the same code in earlier PostgreSQL
> > versions (e.g., PostgreSQL 16).
>
> You are quite mistaken about that.  It's been like this since the
> beginning of plpgsql.
>

While Tom is certainly right about this, I have seen the following
plpgsql code style which looks like the behavior the OP is suggesting,
so they could be mis-remembering.

pagila=# DO $$
DECLARE
    my_var TEXT := 'garth';
BEGIN
    RAISE NOTICE USING message = format('%s is slim', my_var);
END
$$;
NOTICE:  garth is slim
DO


Robert Treat
https://xzilla.net