Jeff Davis <pgsql@j-davis.com> writes:
> On Sat, 2024-03-30 at 13:18 -0400, Tom Lane wrote:
>> Surely they are data, not schema. It would make zero sense to
>> restore them if you aren't restoring the data they describe.
> The complexity is that pg_upgrade does create the data, but relies on a
> schema-only dump. So we'd need to at least account for that somehow,
> either with a separate stats-only dump, or make a special case in
> binary upgrade mode that dumps schema+stats (and resolves the CREATE
> INDEX issue).
Ah, good point. But binary-upgrade mode is special in tons of ways
already. I don't see a big problem with allowing it to dump stats
even though --schema-only would normally imply not doing that.
(You could also imagine an explicit positive --stats switch that would
override --schema-only, but I don't see that it's worth the trouble.)
>> Maybe we need to revisit CREATE INDEX's behavior rather
>> than assuming it's graven in stone?
> Would there be a significant cost to just not doing that? Or are you
> suggesting that we special-case the behavior, or turn it off during
> restore with a GUC?
I didn't have any specific proposal in mind, was just trying to think
outside the box.
regards, tom lane