Re: CSV arm check failure

Marko Kreen wrote:

>On Thu, Jan 06, 2005 at 11:39:14AM -0500, Jim Buttafuoco wrote:
>  
>
>>I couldn't get 2.4.27 to patch with the arm patches, so I downloaded 2.4.25 (with has CONFIG_FPE_NWFPE=y) and ALL 
>>tests passed.  So I will file a bug report with Debian.  We should also put something in the Postgresql readme about

>>this issue.
>>    
>>
>
>I do not think its bug in Debian or kernel - it is expected and
>documented behaviour of FastFPE to have less precision.  Also if
>you think of ARM usage scenarious it seems fine to use lighter
>emulation.
>
>The question is rather how to handle it in PostgreSQL
>regression testing:
>1) Document the need for NWFPE - which gives standard results.
>2) Use FastFPE results on Linux/ARM.
>3) Autodetect - ok, that was a joke.
>
>I guess 1) is fine now.  2) should be done when FastFPE is
>standard on Linux/ARM.
>  
>


Why not just add an alternative regression output? pg_regress is 
designed to handle it, and we have quite a few of those already to deal 
with minor FP differences.

Reminder: here is the complete set of diffs:

*** ./expected/point.out    Tue Jan  4 10:55:16 2005
--- ./results/point.out    Tue Jan  4 12:40:50 2005
***************
*** 101,107 ****      | (-3,4)     |                5      | (-10,0)    |               10      | (-5,-12)   |
    13
 
!      | (10,10)    |  14.142135623731      | (5.1,34.5) | 34.8749193547455 (6 rows)

--- 101,107 ----      | (-3,4)     |                5      | (-10,0)    |               10      | (-5,-12)   |
    13
 
!      | (10,10)    | 14.1421356237309      | (5.1,34.5) | 34.8749193547455 (6 rows)

***************
*** 127,134 ****            | (-5,-12)   | (-10,0)    |               13            | (-5,-12)   | (0,0)      |
     13            | (0,0)      | (-5,-12)   |               13
 
!            | (0,0)      | (10,10)    |  14.142135623731
!            | (10,10)    | (0,0)      |  14.142135623731            | (-3,4)     | (10,10)    | 14.3178210632764
    | (10,10)    | (-3,4)     | 14.3178210632764            | (-5,-12)   | (-3,4)     | 16.1245154965971
 
--- 127,134 ----            | (-5,-12)   | (-10,0)    |               13            | (-5,-12)   | (0,0)      |
     13            | (0,0)      | (-5,-12)   |               13
 
!            | (0,0)      | (10,10)    | 14.1421356237309
!            | (10,10)    | (0,0)      | 14.1421356237309            | (-3,4)     | (10,10)    | 14.3178210632764
    | (10,10)    | (-3,4)     | 14.3178210632764            | (-5,-12)   | (-3,4)     | 16.1245154965971
 
***************
*** 198,204 ****          | (-10,0)    | (0,0)      |               10          | (-10,0)    | (-5,-12)   |
 13          | (-5,-12)   | (0,0)      |               13
 
!          | (0,0)      | (10,10)    |  14.142135623731          | (-3,4)     | (10,10)    | 14.3178210632764
|(-5,-12)   | (-3,4)     | 16.1245154965971          | (-10,0)    | (10,10)    | 22.3606797749979
 
--- 198,204 ----          | (-10,0)    | (0,0)      |               10          | (-10,0)    | (-5,-12)   |
 13          | (-5,-12)   | (0,0)      |               13
 
!          | (0,0)      | (10,10)    | 14.1421356237309          | (-3,4)     | (10,10)    | 14.3178210632764
|(-5,-12)   | (-3,4)     | 16.1245154965971          | (-10,0)    | (10,10)    | 22.3606797749979
 




cheers

andrew