Re: pg_walcleaner - new tool to detect, archive and delete the unneeded wal files (was Re: pg_archivecleanup - add the ability to detect, archive and delete the unneeded wal files on the primary)

On 25.04.22 20:39, Stephen Frost wrote:
> All of which isn't an issue if we don't have an external tool trying to
> do this and instead have the server doing it as the server knows its
> internal status, that the archive command has been failing long enough
> to pass the configuration threshold, and that the WAL isn't needed for
> crash recovery.  The ability to avoid having to crash and go through
> that process is pretty valuable.  Still, a crash may still happen and
> it'd be useful to have a clean way to deal with it.  I'm not really a
> fan of having to essentially configure this external command as well as
> have the server configured.  Have we settled that there's no way to make
> the server archive while there's no space available and before trying to
> write out more data?

I would also be in favor of not having an external command and instead 
pursue a solution built into the server along the ways you have 
outlined.  Besides the better integration and less potential for misuse 
that can be achieved that way, maintaining a separate tool has some 
constant overhead and if users only use it every ten years on average, 
it seems not worth it.