All,
* Alan Hodgson (ahodgson@lists.simkin.ca) wrote:
> On Tue, 2017-11-21 at 10:52 -0800, John R Pierce wrote:
> > it seems to *ME* like a simpler solution to the original problem
> > would have been to simply STRIP any DKIM out of the original
> > messages, and continue to munge headers and footers like mail
> > list
> > reflectors have been doing for decades.
>
> That wouldn't help; DMARC policies are based on the From: header. If
> you want to munge messages from DMARC-reject senders you need to
> replace the From: header with your own.
>
> Email doesn't work the same as it did decades ago. Senders need to keep
> up.
Please, let's take this debate elsewhere, it's not appropriate here. If
you'd really like to discuss further, you're welcome to email me
directly.
Thanks!
Stephen