Re: Add on_perl_init and proper destruction to plperl [PATCH]

Tim Bunce <Tim.Bunce@pobox.com> writes:
> On Wed, Jan 27, 2010 at 06:27:50PM -0500, Tom Lane wrote:
>> An advantage of on_proc_exit from your end is that it should allow
>> you to not have to try to prevent the END blocks from using SPI,
>> as that would still be perfectly functional when your callback
>> gets called.  (Starting a new transaction would be a good idea
>> though, cf Async_UnlistenOnExit.)

> I'm surprised that you're suggesting that END block should be allowed to
> interact with the backend via SPI.  It seems to go against what you've
> said previously about code running at shutdown.

I think you have completely misunderstood what I'm complaining about.
What I'm not happy about is executing operations at a point where
they're likely to be ill-defined because the code is in the wrong state.
In an early on_proc_exit hook, the system is for all practical purposes
still fully functional, and so I don't see a reason for an arbitrary
restriction on what the END blocks should be able to do.

(Or, to repeat myself in a different way: the no-SPI restriction is
utterly useless to guard against my real concerns anyway.  I see no
point in it either here or elsewhere.)
        regards, tom lane