Re: Re: BUG #8444: ERROR: table name "tblb" specified more than once in subquery

David Johnston <polobo@yahoo.com> writes:
>> Here is a minimal query that demonstrates the problem.  In 9.1 it works:
>>
>> chris=# select * FROM current_user u join (current_user u cross join
>> current_user v) x on true;
>>
>> On 9.3 it fails:
>> ERROR:  table name "u" specified more than once

This is an intentional change that came in with the LATERAL feature.
The query is illegal per SQL spec but we used to allow it anyway,
on the theory that the table name "u" inside the aliased join "x"
wasn't visible anywhere that the other "u" was visible, so the
duplicate alias name was harmless.  But in the presence of LATERAL
it's not harmless; consider

select * FROM current_user u join
  (current_user u cross join LATERAL (select u.x) v) x on true;

Which instance of "u" does the lateral reference refer to?

(I think there was some discussion of this in the pgsql-hackers list
about a year ago, but I couldn't find it in a desultory search.)

            regards, tom lane