Re: adding support for posix_fadvise()

On Mon, 2003-11-03 at 09:38, Tom Lane wrote:
> Neil Conway <neilc@samurai.com> writes:
> > Given a Relation and an advice, this would:
> > (a) propagate the advice for this relation to all the open FDs for the
> > relation
> 
> "All"?  You cannot affect the FDs being used by other backends.

Sorry, I meant just the FDs opened by this backend.

> It's fairly unclear to me what the posix_fadvise function is really
> going to do for files that are being accessed by multiple processes.

In a thread on lkml[1], Andrew Morton comments:
       Note that it applies to a file descriptor. If       posix_fadvise(FADV_DONTNEED) is called against a file
descriptor,and someone else has an fd open against the same       file, that other user gets their foot shot off.
That'sOK.
 

I would imagine that by "getting their foot" shot off, Andrew is saying
that FADV_DONTNEED by one process affects any other processes accessing
the same file via a different FD. If I'm misunderstanding what's going
on here, please let me know.

> For instance, is there any value in setting POSIX_FADV_DONTNEED on a
> WAL file, given that every other backend is going to have that same
> file open?

My understanding is that yes, there is value in doing this, for the
reasons mentioned above.

> A related problem is that the smgr uses the same FD to access the same
> relation no matter how many scans are in progress.

Interesting ... I'll have to think some more about this. Thanks for the
suggestions and comments.

-Neil

[1] - http://www.ussg.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/0203.2/0361.html

The rest of the thread includes an interesting discussion -- I recommend
reading it. The lkml folks actually speculate about what we (OSS DBMS
developers) would find useful in fadvise(), amusingly enough... The
thread starts here:

http://www.ussg.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/0203.2/0230.html

Finally, Andrew Morton provides some more clarification on what happens
when multiple processes are accessing a file that is fadvise()'d:

http://www.ussg.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/0203.2/0476.html