Re: Weird behavior in transaction handling (Possible bug ?)

So correct me if I'm wrong.

even in psql you are getting no error message from the commit statement?

The driver can't possibly know when something is going to fail.

Dave

j.random.programmer wrote:

an error. And I don't believe commit fails silently,
it should give you
an error.   

Nope, no error. See the original post, there isn't any
error
in the postgresql logs either, and no error at the
JDBC layer.
 

(notably Oracle). So I would expect you're coming
from an oracle DB
experience...   

Nope. I've been using Postgresql for years now (after
having
used mysql/innodb and gotten rather tired of _that_). 

:-]
 

Please note that setting a savepoint in postgres is
not nearly free, so
be careful how often you do it.   

After further testing, the standalone psql client also
shows
the same behavior so I guess this is a postgresql
database
thing, not driver specific.

Here's my humble suggestion. If technically possible,
have 
the driver throw a SQLExeption when trying to commit()

and when the driver knows that commit() is going to
fail.

Maybe the driver can simple track if it's recieved any
kind
of error messages on a given connection. If so, then
when
commit() is called on that connection, the driver
should 
throw a SQLException ?

Otherwise, you're asking for very esoteric bugs to say
you have
commit() succesfully yet  fail silently. That's more
like a mysql 
thing, *not* a postgresql thing right ?

Best regards,

--j



	
__________________________________ 
Do you Yahoo!? 
Meet the all-new My Yahoo! - Try it today! 
http://my.yahoo.com 


---------------------------(end of broadcast)---------------------------
TIP 8: explain analyze is your friend

 

-- 
Dave Cramer
http://www.postgresintl.com
519 939 0336
ICQ#14675561