Обсуждение: [Code Cleanup] : Small code cleanup in twophase.sql

Поиск
Список
Период
Сортировка

[Code Cleanup] : Small code cleanup in twophase.sql

От
Nishant Sharma
Дата:
Hi,


PFA small code cleanup in twophase.sql. Which contains a drop table
statement for 'test_prepared_savepoint'. Which, to me, appears to be
missing in the cleanup section of that file.

To support it I have below points:-

1) Grepping this table 'test_prepared_savepoint' shows occurrences
only in twophase.out & twophase.sql files. This means that table is
local to that sql test file and not used in any other test file.

2) I don't see any comment on why this was not added in the cleanup
section of twophase.sql, but drop for other two test tables are done.

3) I ran "make check-world" with the patch and I don't see any failures.

Kindly correct, if I missed anything.


Regards,
Nishant (EDB).
Вложения

Re: [Code Cleanup] : Small code cleanup in twophase.sql

От
Nishant Sharma
Дата:
Hi,

Any taker or rejector for above? -- It's a very small 'good to have' change patch for cleanup.

Thanks,
Nishant (EDB).

On Tue, Sep 26, 2023 at 6:31 PM Nishant Sharma <nishant.sharma@enterprisedb.com> wrote:
Hi,


PFA small code cleanup in twophase.sql. Which contains a drop table
statement for 'test_prepared_savepoint'. Which, to me, appears to be
missing in the cleanup section of that file.

To support it I have below points:-

1) Grepping this table 'test_prepared_savepoint' shows occurrences
only in twophase.out & twophase.sql files. This means that table is
local to that sql test file and not used in any other test file.

2) I don't see any comment on why this was not added in the cleanup
section of twophase.sql, but drop for other two test tables are done.

3) I ran "make check-world" with the patch and I don't see any failures.

Kindly correct, if I missed anything.


Regards,
Nishant (EDB).

Re: [Code Cleanup] : Small code cleanup in twophase.sql

От
Michael Paquier
Дата:
On Tue, Sep 26, 2023 at 06:31:42PM +0530, Nishant Sharma wrote:
> To support it I have below points:-
>
> 1) Grepping this table 'test_prepared_savepoint' shows occurrences
> only in twophase.out & twophase.sql files. This means that table is
> local to that sql test file and not used in any other test file.
>
> 2) I don't see any comment on why this was not added in the cleanup
> section of twophase.sql, but drop for other two test tables are done.
>
> 3) I ran "make check-world" with the patch and I don't see any failures.

Note that sometimes tables are left around in the regression tests for
pg_upgrade, so as we can test dedicated upgrade paths for some object
types.  But, here, I think you're right: this is not a table that
matters for an upgrade and the end of the test file also expects a
cleanup.  So okay for me to drop this table here.
--
Michael
Вложения